Between Action and Language: Processes of Wittgensteinian Linguistic Learning in the light of Tomasello’s Evolutional Studies on Collective Intentionality

Marco Gigante

Marco Gigante

Keywords: Wittgenstein, Tomasello, language acquisition, joint attention, cooperative communication

Abstract

This article focuses on the critical comparison between some of Wittgenstein’s intuitions on language acquisition and Tomasello’s theory of the human joint attentional processes in early childhood. Firstly, this essay will explore the problematic nature of the relations between pre-verbal behavior and linguistic games, which Wittgenstein analyses in the late phase of his philosophical study. The second part of this essay will shift attention onto Tomasello’s assumptions about the pre-modern Homo and his social-cognitive abilities, in the attempt to reveal their dependence on the interaction with the surrounding environment. Overall, this essay sets itself to achieve a double goal: on the one hand, that of illustrating how some aspects of Wittgenstein’s philosophical theory converge with Tomasello’s elaboration of the early human cooperative communication processes; on the other, that of showing the potential contribution of Tomasello’s work to the development of Wittgenstein’s insights on the process of language acquisition.

References

Baker, Gordon Park e Peter Michael Stephan, Hacker (1980), Understanding and Meaning: An Analytical Commentary on Wittgenstein’s Philosophical Investigations, vol. 1, Blackwell, Oxford.

Baker, Gordon Park e Peter Michael Stephan, Hacker (1983), Wittgenstein: Rules, Grammar and Necessity, Blackwell, Oxford.

Lynne Rudder, Baker (1984), «On the very Idea of a Form of Life», in Inquiry, n. 27, pp. 277-289.

Canfield, John (1996), Wittgenstein’s Later Philosophy, in J.V. Canfield (ed.), Philosophy of Meaning, Knowledge and Value in the Twentieh Century. Routledge History of Philosophy, vol. X, Routledge, London, pp. 247-285.

Chomsky, Noam (2006), Linguistics and Philosophy, in Language and Mind, 3rd Edition, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge pp. 143-172.

Coliva, Annalisa (2003), Moore e Wittgenstein. Scetticismo, certezza e senso comune, Il Poligrafo, Padova.

Coliva, Annalisa (2010), «Was Wittgenstein an Epistemic Relativist?», in Philosophical Investigations, n. 33, 1, pp. 1-23.

Conway, Gertrude Dolores (1989), Wittgenstein on Foundations, Humanities Press International, Atlantic Highlands.

Emmett, Kathleen (1990), «Forms of life», in Philosophical Investigations, n. 13, 3, pp. 213-231.

Finkelstein, David (2003), Expression and the Inner, Harvard University Press, London.

Fodor, Jerry Alan (1975), The Language of Thought, The Harvester Press, Brighton.

Forsberg, Niklas; Burley, Mikel e Hämäläinen, Nora (ed. 2012), Language, Ethics and Animal Life. Wittgenstein and Beyond, Bloomsbury, London, New York.

Garver, Mewton (1994), This Complicated Form of Life: Essays on Wittgenstein, Open Court, Chicago.

Gier, Nicholas (1980), «Wittgenstein and Forms of life», in Philosophy and the Social Science, n. 10, pp. 241-258.

Glock, Hans Johann (2000), «Animals, Thoughts and Concepts», in Synthese, n. 123, p. 36.

Glock, Hans Johann (2010), «Can Animals Judge? », in Dialectica, n. 64, 1, pp. 11-33.

Hacker, Peter (1972), Insight and Illusion, Oxford University Press, London 1972.

Hacker Peter (2015), «Forms of life», in Nordic Wittgenstein Review, Special Issue: Wittgenstein and Forms of life, https://www.nordicwittgensteinreview.com/article/view/33

Hilmy, Stephen (1987), The Later Wittgenstein: The Emergence of a New Philosophical Method, Blackwell, Oxford.

Hilmy, Stephen (1989), «Wittgenstein and Behaviourism», in Grazer Philosophische Studien, n. 33-34, pp. 335-352.

Mazzeo, Marco (2016), Il bambino e l’operaio. Wittgenstein filosofo dell’uso, Quodlibet, Macerata.

McGinn, Colin (1984), Wittgenstein on Meaning. An interpretation and Evaluation, Blackwell, Oxford.

Moore, George Edward (1959), Philosophical Papers, Allen & Unwin, London (Saggi filosofici, trad. di M. A. Bonfantini, Lampugnani Nigri, Milano 1970).

Moyal-Sharrock, Danièle (2007), Understanding Wittgenstein’s On Certainty, Palgrave Macmillan, Basingstoke 2007.

Moyal-Sharrock, Danièle (2010), Coming to Language: Wittgenstein’s Social ‘Theory’ of Language, in V. Munz, K. Puhl & J Wang (eds.), Language and World, Part One: Essays on the Philosophy of Wittgenstein, Ontos Verlag, Frankfurt am Main, pp. 291-314.

Moyal-Sharrock, Danièle (2013), «Wittgenstein’s Razor: The Cutting Edge of Enactivism», in American Philosophical Quarterly, n. 50, 3, pp. 263-280.

Morawetz, Thomas (1978), Wittgenstein and Knowledge: The importance of “On Certainty”, University of Massachussets Press, Amherst.

Perissinotto, Luigi (1991), Logica e immagine del mondo. Studio su Über Gewissheit di Wittgenstein, Guerini e Associati, Milano.

Searle, John (1995), The construction of social reality, Free Press, New York (La costruzione della realtà sociale trad. di A. Bosco, Einaudi, Torino 2006.

Stroll, Avrum (1987), Moore and Wittgenstein on Certainty, Oxford University Press, New York.

Tomasello, Michael; Kruger, Ann Cale e Ratner Hilary Horn (1993), «Cultural learning», in Behavioral and Brain Sciences, n. 16, pp. 449-452.

Tomasello, Michael (1999), The Cultural Origins of Human Cognition, Harvard University Press, Cambridge (MA) (Le origini culturali della cognizione umana, trad. di L. Anolli, Il Mulino, Bologna 2005).

Tomasello, Michael (2008), Origins of Human Communication, MIT Press, Cambridge (MA) (Le origini della comunicazione umana, trad. di S. Romano, Raffaello Cortina, Milano 2009).

Tomasello, Michael (2014), A Natural History of Human Thinking, Harvard University Press, Cambridge (MA) (Unicamente umano. Storia naturale del pensiero, trad. di M. Ricucci, Il Mulino, Bologna 2014).

Williamson, Timothy (2000), Knowledge and its Limits, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

Wolgast, Elizabeth (1994), «Primitive Reactions», in Philosophical Investigations, n. 17, 4, pp. 587-603.

Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1953), Philosophisce Untersuchungen, a cura di G. E. Anscombe e R. Rhees, Blackwell, Oxford (Ricerche filosofiche, trad. di R. Piovesan e M. Trinchero, Einaudi, Torino 1983). (PU).

Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1969), The Blue Book in The Blue and Brown Books, a cura di R. Rhees, Blackwell, Oxford (Libro blu, in Libro blu e libro marrone, trad. di A. G. Conte, Einaudi, Torino 2002). (BlB).

Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1969), The Brown Book, in The Blue and Brown Books, a cura di R. Rhees, Blackwell, Oxford, (Libro marrone, in Libro blu e libro marrone, trad. di A. G. Conte, Einaudi, Torino 2002). (BrB).

Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1969), Philosophische Grammatik, a cura di R. Rhees, Blackwell, Oxford, (Grammatica filosofica, trad. di M. Trinchero, La Nuova Italia, Firenze 1990). (PG).

Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1967), Zettel, a cura di G. E. M. Anscombe e G. H. von Wright, Blackwell, Oxford (Zettel, trad. di M. Trinchero, Einaudi, Torino 1986). (Z).

Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1969), Über Gewissheit, a cura di G. E. M. Anscombe, Blackwell, Oxford (Della certezza. L’analisi filosofica del senso comune, trad. di M. Trinchero, Einaudi, Torino 1978). (UG).

Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1977), Vermischte Bemerkungen, a cura di G. H. von Wright, Suhrkamp, Frankfurt am Main (Pensieri Diversi, trad. di M. Ranchetti, Adelphi, Milano 1980). (VB).

Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1980), Bemerkungen über die Philosophie der Psychologie, a cura di G. E. M. Anscombe, G. H. von Wright e H. Nyman, Blackwell, Oxford (Osservazioni sulla filosofia della psicologia, trad. di R. De Monticelli, Adelphi, Milano 1990). (BPP).

Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1956), Bemerkungen über die Grundlagen der Mathematik, a cura di G. H. von Wright, R. Rhees e G. E. M. Anscombe, Frankfurt am Main 1984 (Osservazioni sopra i fondamenti della matematica, trad. di M. Trinchero, Einaudi, Torino 1988). (BGM).

Wittgenstein, Ludwig (1989), Wittgenstein’s Lectures on the Foundation of Mathematics. Cambridge, 1939: from the notes of E. G. Bosanquet, N. Malcolm, R. Rhees, Y. Smythies, a cura di C. Diamond, University of Chicago Press, Chicago (Lezioni sui fondamenti della matematica, trad. di E. Picardi, Bollati Boringhieri, Torino 2002). (LFM).

Wittgenstein, Ludwig (2005) The Big Typescript: TS 213 German English Scholars’ Edition, a cura di C. Grant Luckhardt e Maximilian E. Aue, Wiley-Blackwell, Oxford (The big Typescript, trad. di A. De Palma, Einaudi, Torino 2002). (BT)