Slurs and the Type-Token Distinction of Their Derogatory Force

Chang Liu

Chang Liu

Keywords: Slurs, Pejoratives, Derogatory Force, Offensiveness, Type-token Distinction

Abstract

Slurs are derogatory, and theories of slurs aim at explaining their “derogatory force”. This paper draws a distinction between the type derogatory force and the token derogatory force of slurs. To explain the type derogatory force is to explain why a slur is a derogatory word. By contrast, to explain the token derogatory force is to explain why an utterance of a slur is derogatory. This distinction will be defended by examples in which the type and the token derogatory force come apart. Because of the distinction, an adequate theory of slurs must be plausible for both the type and the token derogatory force. However, I will argue that many theories fail to be plausible for both. In particular, Hom’s combinatorial externalism and the conventional implicature theory offer implausible accounts of the token derogatory force, whereas the prohibitionist theory is insufficient to explain the type derogatory force.

References

Anderson, Luvell, & Lepore, Ernie (2013), «What Did You Call Me? Slurs as Prohibited Words», in Analytic Philosophy, vol. 54, n. 3, pp. 350-363.

Davidson, Donald (1970), Mental Events, in Foster, L. and Swanson, J. W., eds., Essays on Actions and Events, Clarendon Press, pp. 207-224.

Diaz-Legaspe, Justina, Chang Liu, & Stainton, Robert J. (2019), «Slurs and Register: A Case Study in Meaning Pluralism», in Mind and Language, n. 34, pp 1-17.

Grice, H. Paul (1989), Studies in the Way of Words, Harvard University Press, Cambridge (MA).

Hom, Christopher (2008), «The Semantics of Racial Epithets», in Journal of Philosophy, vol. 105, n. 8, pp. 416-440.

Hom, Christopher (2010), «Pejoratives», in Philosophy Compass, vol. 5, n. 2, pp. 164-185.

Hom, Christopher (2012), «A puzzle about pejoratives», in Philosophical Studies, vol. 159, n. 3, pp. 383-405.

Hom, Christopher & May, Robert (2013), «Moral and Semantic Innocence», in Analytic Philosophy, vol. 54, n. 3, pp. 293-313.

Kennedy, Randall (2003), Nigger: The Strange Career of a Troublesome Word, Vintage Books, New York.

Schlenker, Philippe (2007), «Expressive Presuppositions», in Theoretical Linguistics, vol. 33, n. 2, pp. 237-245.

Smart, J. J. C. (1959), «Sensations and Brain Processes», in Philosophical Review, vol. 68, n. 2, pp. 141-56.

Whiting, Daniel (2013), «It’s Not What You Said, It’s the Way You Said It: Slurs and Conventional Implicatures», in Analytic Philosophy, vol. 54, n. 3, pp. 364-377.

Williamson, Timothy (2009), Reference, inference, and the semantics of pejoratives, in Almog, J. and Leonardi, P., eds., The Philosophy of David Kaplan, Oxford University Press, Oxford, pp. 137-159.

Wollheim, Richard (1968), Art and Its Objects, Harper and Row, New York.

Wright, Richard (1993), The Ethics of Living Jim Crow, in Wright, R., Uncle Tom’s Children, Harper Perennial, New York.