Simbolicità e emotività negli animali non umani: un tema attuale con radici lontane

Stefano Gensini; Giulia Palazzolo

doi:10.4396/SFL2019ESC04

Stefano Gensini
Giulia Palazzolo

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4396/SFL2019ESC04

Keywords: Non-human communication systems, Emotions, Symbolism, Intentionality, Cognitive ethology

Abstract

Are the communication systems of non-human animals endowed with the property of symbolism or are they merely expressions of emotional states? The question has pervaded the philosophical debate at least since the time of Descartes and is now abundantly discussed in the field of cognitive ethology. In this paper, the topic is summarized both from the philosophical point of view (reconsidering Brentan’s notion of ‘intentionality’, often referred to by ethologists, too) and from the experimental point of view, referring to some well-known case-studies of the last decades. It is suggested that a dichotomous, all-or-nothing, vision of the relationship between symbolism and emotionality is, today, outdated in both conceptual and methodological terms. Available evidence on the communication of different primate species shows that the two components interact closely. An embodied approach to animal communication seems to represent an effective way out also from a theoretical point of view.

References

Benveniste, Émile (1953), «Animal Communication and Human Language. The Language of the Bees», in Diogenes, vol. 1, n. 1, pp. 1-7.

Brentano, Franz C. (1874), Psychologie vom Empyrischen Standpunkte I, Meiner, Hamburg, 1973.

Cassirer, Ernst (1944), An Essay on Man. An Introduction to a Philosophy of Culture, Yale University Press, New Haven.

Cheney, Dorothy L. e Seyfarth, Robert M. (1992), «Précis of How monkeys see the world», in Behavioral and Brain Sciences, vol. 15, pp. 135-182.

Damasio, António R. (1994), Descartes’ error: Emotion, rationality and the human brain, New York, Putnam.

Darwin, Charles (1874), The Descent of Man and Selection in Relation to Sex, 2nd ed., revised and augmented, John Murray, London.

Darwin, Charles (1872), The Expression of the Emotions in Man and Animals, John Murray, London.

Dawkins, Richard e Krebs, John R. (1978), Animal signals: information or manipulation, in Krebs, John R. e Davies, Nicholas B., a cura di, Behavioural Ecology: an Evolutionary Approach, Blackwell Scientific, Oxford, pp. 282-309.

Dennett, Daniel C. (1983), «Intentional systems in cognitive ethology: The ‘Panglossian paradigm’ defended», in The Behavioral and Brain Sciences, vol. 6, pp. 343-390.

Dennett, Daniel C. (1971), «Intentional systems», in The Journal of Philosophy, vol. 68, pp. 87-106.

Dennett, Daniel C. (1987), The Intentional Stance, MIT Press, Cambridge (MA).

Fouts, Roger (1997), Next of Kin: what chimpanzees have taught me about who we are, William Morrow and Company, New York,.

Frisch, Karl von (1950), Bees. Their Vision, chemical Senses, and Language, Cornell University Press, Ithaca, New York.

Gassendi, Pierre (1644), «Objectiones quintae eximio viro Renato Cartesio», in Oeuvres de Descartes publiées par C. Adam et P.Tannery […]. VII. Meditationes de prima philosophia, Léopold Cerf, Paris, 1904, pp. 256-346.

Gensini, Stefano (2018), A proposito di zoosemiotica: gli inizi della storia, in Bruno, M. W. et. al., a cura di, Linguistica e filosofia del linguaggio. Studi in onore di Daniele Gambarara, Mimesis, Milano, pp. 263-282.

Griffin, Donald R. (1976), The Question of Animal Awareness. Evolutionary Continuity of Mental Experience, The Rockefeller University Press, New York.

Griffin, Donald R. (1995), «Windows on Animal Minds», in Cosciousness and Cognition, vol. 4, pp. 194-204.

Köhler, Wolfgang (1921), «Zur Psychologie des Schimpansen», in Psychologische Forschungen, vol. I, pp. 2-46 (trad. ingl. di E. Winter, Some Contributions to the Psychology of Chimpanzees, in Id., The Mentality of Apes, 2nd rev. Ed., The Humanities Press-Routledge & Kegan Paul, New York-London, 1951, pp. 271-329).

Liebal, Katja e Oña, Linda (2018), “Different Approaches to Meaning in Primate Gestural and Vocal Communication”, in Frontiers in Psychology, vol. 9, n. 478, pp. 1-7.

Herder, Johann G. (1772), Üben den Ursprung der Sprache. Text, Materialien, Kommentar, hg. v. W. Pross, Carl Hanser Verlag, München/Wien, 1978.

Manser, Marta B., Bell, Matthew B. e Fletcher, Lindsay B. (2001), «The information that receivers extract from alarm calls in suricates», in Proceedings of the Royal Society B, vol. 268, pp. 2845-2491.

Marler, Peter, Evans, Christopher S. e Hauser, Marc D. (1992), Animal signals: referential, motivational or both?, in Hanuš, Papoušek, Jürgens, Uwe e Papoušek, Mechthild, a cura di, Nonverbal Vocal Communication. Comparative and Developmental Approaches, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 66-86.

Ogden, Charles e Richards, Ivor (1923), The Meaning of Meaning. A Study of the Influence of Language upon thought and of the Science of Symbolism, Harcourt, Brace & World, INC., New York, 1956.

Putnam, Hilary W. (1960), Mind and machines, in Hook, Sidney, a cura di, Dimensions of Mind: A Symposium, New York University Press, New York.

Rendall, Drew, Owren, Michael J. e Ryan, Michael J. (2009), «What do animal signals mean?», in Animal Behaviour, vol. 78, pp. 233-240.

Sebeok, Thomas A. (1965), Animal Communication, in «Science», vol. 147, pp. 1006-1014.

Seyfarth, Robert M., Cheney, Dorothy L. e Marler, Peter (1980), «Monkey responses to three different alarm calls: Evidence of predator classification and semantic communication», in Science, vol. 210, pp. 801-803.

Seyfarth, Robert M., Cheney, Dorothy L., Bergman, Thore, Fischer, Julia, Zuberbühler, Klaus e Hammerschmidt, Kurt (2010), «The central importance of information in studies of animal communication», in Animal Behaviour, vol. 80, pp. 3-8.

Struhsaker, Thomas T. (1967), «Ecology of Vervet Monkeys (Cercopithecus Aethiops) in The Masai-Amboseli Game Reserve, Kenya», in Ecology, vol. 48, n. 6, pp. 891-904.

Varela, Francisco J., Thompson, Evan e Rosch, Eleanor (1991), The Embodied Mind. Cognitive Science and Human Experience, The MIT Press, Cambridge (MA).

Wheeler, Brandon C. e Fischer, Julia (2012), «Functionally Referential Signals: A Promising Paradigm Whose Time Has Passed», in Evolutionary Anthropology, vol. 21, pp. 195-205.

Zuberbühler, Klaus, Cheney, Dorothy L. e Seyfarth, Robert M. (1999), «Conceptual semantics in a nonhuman primate», in Journal of Comparative Psychology, vol. 113, n. 1, pp. 33-42.