Is mediation violence? A critique of identity politics

Marco Mazzone

doi:10.4396/20240615M

Marco Mazzone

DOI: https://doi.org/10.4396/20240615M

Parole chiave: Identity politics, Mediation, Recognition, Universality, Politically Correct

Abstract

By «identity politics» (see Lilla 2017) I intend a political project closely based on the defense of the rights of individuals and minorities. Here, I analyze a problematic assumption that is sometimes made by the advocates of that project: the idea that, since difference is a value, no mediation is necessary, or even that behind every search for mediation lies a claim to universality that constitutes a form of violence. The dual purpose of this article is to challenge that critique of mediation through an analysis of the notion of universality, and to argue that the strategy proposed by identity politics is ultimately anti-political.

Riferimenti bibliografici

Andronico, Alberto (2011), Presentare l’universale. Il problema dei diritti umani, in Pirrone, Pasquale (2011), Circolazione dei valori giuridici e tutela dei diritti e delle libertà fondamentali, Torino, Giappichelli.

Bianchi, Claudia, (2021), Hate speech. Il lato oscuro del linguaggio, Roma-Bari, Laterza.

Butler, Judith (1997), Excitable Speech. A Politics of the Performative, New York-London, Routledge.

Campisi, Emanuela, Mazzone, Marco, Venuti, Marco, Politically Correct and In/Exclusion: A nonIdeal Perspective, in Russo, Valentina, Piccirilli, Eduardo Maria, Linguistica ed economia III. Inclusione e digitalizzazione, Napoli, Academy School.

Esposito, Roberto (2023), Vitam instituere. Genealogia dell’istituzione, Torino, Einaudi.

Fraser, Nancy, Honneth, Axel (2003), Redistribution or Recognition? A Political-Philosophical Exchange, London-New York, Verso.

Lilla, Mark (2017), The Once and Future Liberal. After Identity Politics, New York, Harper Collins.

Mazzone, Marco (2020), Performativity and the Ideological Construction of the Self. The Age of Narcissism and (Possibly) Beyond, in Pennisi, Antonino e Falzone, Alessandra (2020), The Extended Theory of Cognitive Creativity. Interdisciplinary Approaches to Performativity, Chaim, Springer.

Mazzone, Marco (2023), Razionali fino in fondo. Dal pensiero ideologico al pensiero critico, Macerata, Quodlibet.

Orsina, Giovanni (2018), La democrazia del narcisismo. Breve storia dell’antipolitica, Venezia, Marsilio.

Renault, Emmanuel (2007), «Riconoscimento, lotta, dominio. Il modello hegeliano» in Postfilosofie, vol. 4, pp. 29-45.

Sbisà, Marina (2021), (Im)politeness and the Human Subject, in Xie, Chaoqun (2021), The Philosophy of(Im)politeness, Cham, Springer.