La nozione di “mente estesa” tra scienze cognitive, semiotica e pragmatismo. Alcune riflessioni a partire dal tema del linguaggio

Marta Caravà

Marta Caravà

Abstract

In this paper, I will investigate the notion of mind within the “Extended Mind” theory, as it is defended by Andy Clark. The aim is to provide an explanation of its key ideas and to highlight some of its consequences. In the first part I will briefly explain the main features of Clark's theory. In the second part, I will discuss his account of the nature of language and its relationship to cognition, and I will relate it with the arguments for cognitive and mental extension. Then I will use my analysis of Clark's arguments in order to individuate some problems, which characterize his philosophical position. Although I am sympathetic with his theory, I will argue that it is nonetheless committed to a narrow account of cognition and mind. For this reason, I will propose a way to integrate Clark's theory within a semiotic and pragmatist framework inspired by C.S. Peirce. I suggest that, if we conceive the cognition as a semiotic sense-making process, we can provide a broad account of cognition and a fully externalist position about mind

References

ADAMS, Fred, AIZAWA, Ken (2009), Why the Mind is Still in the Head, in ROBBINS, P., AYDEDE, M. (a cura di), The Cambridge Handbook on Situated Cognition, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge pp. 78-95.

ATÃ, Pedro, QUEIROZ, João (2014), Icon and Abduction: Situatedness in Peircean Cognitive Semiotics, in MAGNANI, L. (a cura di), Model-Based Reasoning in Science and Technology. Theoretical and Cognitive Issues, Springer, Heidelberg/Berlin, pp. 301-314.

AYDIN, Ciano (2015), «The artifactual mind: overcoming the ‘inside–outside’ dualism in the extended mind thesis and recognizing the technological dimension of cognition», in Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences, n. 14(1), pp. 73-94.

BURKE, Tom (2008), «(Anti) Realist Implications of a Pragmatist Dual-Process ActiveExternalist Theory of Experience», in Philosophia Scientiae, n. 12(1), pp. 187-211.

BURKE, Tom (2014), Extended Mind and Representation, in SHOOK, J. R., SOLYMOSI, T. (a cura di), Pragmatist Neurophilosophy. American Philosophy and the Brain, Bloomsbury Publishing, New York/London, pp. 177-202.

CALCATERRA, Rosa Maria (2006), Psicologia e normatività. Figure dell'esternalismo, in CALCATERRA, R. M. (a cura di), Le ragioni del conoscere e dell'agire. Scritti in onore di Rosaria Egidi, Franco Angeli, Milano, pp. 30-43.

CLARK, Andy (1997), Being there: Putting Brain, Body and World Together Again, MIT Press, Cambridge (MA) (trad. it. Dare Corpo alla Mente, McGraw-Hill, Milano, 1999).

CLARK, Andy (1998), Magic Words: How Language augments Human Computation, in CARRUTHERS, P., BOUCHER, J. (a cura di), Language And Thought: Interdisciplinary Themes, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge, pp. 162-183.

CLARK, Andy (2003), Natural-Born Cyborgs: Technologies and the Future of Human Intelligence, Oxford University Press, Oxford.

CLARK, Andy (2005), «Word, Niche, Super-Niche: How Language Makes Mind Matter More», in Theoria, n.3, pp. 255-268.

CLARK, Andy (2006), «Language, embodiment and the cognitive niche», in Trends in Cognitive Sciences, n. 8, pp. 370–374.

CLARK, Andy (2006), «Material Symbols», in Philosophical Psychology, Vol. 19, n. 3, pp.1-17.

CLARK, Andy (2008), Supersizing the Mind. Embodiment, Action and Cognitive Extension, Oxford University Press, New York.

CLARK, Andy, CHALMERS, David (1998), «The Extended Mind», in Analysis n. 58 (1), pp. 7-19.

DADDESIO, Thomas (1995), On Minds and Symbols. The Relevance of Cognitive Science for Semiotics, Mouton de Gruyter, Berlin/New York.

DI FRANESCO, Michele, PIREDDA, Giulia (2012), La mente estesa. Dove finisce la mente e dove inizia il resto del mondo? Mondadori, Milano.

DI FRANCESCO, Michele (2004), «Mente distribuita e unità del soggetto», in Networks, Rivista Elettronica di Filosofia, n. 3-4, pp. 115- 139.

FABBRICHESI, Rossella (1986), Sulle tracce del segno. Semiotica, faneroscopia e cosmologia nel pensiero di C.S. Peirce, La Nuova Italia, Firenze.

FADDA, Emanuele (2013), Peirce, Carocci, Roma.

GALLAGHER, Shaun (2011), «The Overextended Mind», in Versus-Quaderno di Studi Semiotici, n. 112-113, pp. 57-68.

GALLAGHER, Shaun (2013), «The socially extended mind», in Cognitive System Research, n. 26- 26, pp. 4- 12.

HURLEY, Susan (2010), The varieties of externalism, in MENARY, R. (a cura di), The Extended Mind, MIT Press, Cambridge (MA), pp. 100-153.

HUTCHINS, Edwin (1995), Cognition in the wild, MIT Press, Cambridge (MA).

IBRI, Ivo Assad (2011), Semiotics and epistemology: the pragmatic ground of communication, in CALCATERRA, R. M. (a cura di), New Perspectives on Pragmatism and Analyitic Philosophy, Rodopi, Amsterdam/New York, pp. 71-82.

MEYERS, Robert G. (1999), «Pragmatism and Peirce's Externalist Epistemology», in Transactions of the C. S. Peirce Society, n. 35(4), pp. 638-653.

NÖTH, Winfried (2010), «The Criterion of Habit in Peirce's Definitions of the Symbol», in Transactions of the Charles S. Peirce Society, n. 46(1), pp. 83-93.

PAOLUCCI, Claudio (2011), «The External Mind: Semiotics, Pragmatism, Extended Mind and Distributed Cognition», in Versus-Quaderno di Studi Semiotici, n.112-113, pp. 69-96.

PATERNOSTER, Alfredo (2005), I fondamenti epistemologici della “nuova scienza” cognitiva, in FLORIDI, L. (a cura di), Linee di Ricerca, pp. 594-633.

PEIRCE, Charles Sanders (1931-58), Collected Papers of Charles S. Peirce, HARTSHORNE, C. (vol. I-VI, a cura di), BURKS, W. (vol. VII- VIII, a cura di), Harvard University Press, Cambridge (MA).

PEIRCE, Charles Sanders (1967), Manoscritti inediti di Charles Sanders Peirce, ROBIN, R.S. (numerazione presentata in), Annotated catalogue of Charles Sanders Peirce, University of Massachussetts Press, Amherst.

PEIRCE, Charles Sanders (1984), Writings of Charles S. Peirce: A Chronological Edition, Vol. II: 1867-1871, Indiana University Press, Bloomington-Indianapolis.

ROWLANDS, Mark (2010), The New Science of the Mind. From Extended Mind to Embodied Phenomenology, MIT Press, Cambridge (MA).

RUPERT, Robert D. (2009), Cognitive Systems and Extended Mind, Oxford University Press, New York.

STEFFENSEN, Sune Vork (2011), Beyond mind: an extended ecology of languaging, in COWLEY, S. J. (a cura di), Distributed language, John Benjamins Publishing, Amsterdam, pp.185–210.

SKAGESTAD, Peter (2004), Peirce's Semeiotic Model of the Mind, in MISAK, C. (a cura di), The Cambridge Companion to Peirce, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge (MA), pp. 241-256.

WHEELER, Michael (2004), «Is language the ultimate artefact?», in Language Sciences, n.26 (6), pp. 688-710.