The two faces of appetite: Relevance and the question of food as art
Abstract
Can there be “languages of food” in Nelson Goodman’s sense of “languages of art”? Food appears like a borderline case because of its strong dependence on context and on the individuals involved. We seem to have difficulty either comparing food with language or seeing it as art. This is at odds with the fact that food has been recognized as an art form for decades by art institutions. The paper approaches this problem on a level often neglected in the discussion: pragmatics, the application of language in context. Cognitive scientists Deirdre Wilson and Dan Sperber have shown that the use of language is ultimately based not on rules, but on relevance. Relevance in turn depends on contexts and individuals. Such dependence, therefore, does not make food a borderline case. Rather, it is something that food and language have in common. But can we use a concept of relevance to analyze food? Following the phenomenology of Alfred Schutz, relevance has two sides, termed here “typicality” and “spontaneity”. Both sides of relevance are found to shape our experience of food in striking ways. Food is a particularly clear example of a more general, relevance-driven context dependence of both language and the arts.References
BARTHES, Roland (1961), Toward a Psychosociology of Contemporary Food Consumption, in COUNIHAN Carole, VAN ESTERIK Penny (eds.), Food and Culture. A Reader, Routledge, New York-London 2013, pp. 20-27.
BOURDIEU, Pierre (1979), Distinction: A Social Critique of the Judgement of Taste, Harvard UP, Cambridge, Mass. 1984.
BRADY, Emily (2012), Smells, Tastes, and Everyday Aesthetics, in KAPLAN, David M. (ed.), The Philosophy of Food, Berkeley, University of California Press, Los Angeles, pp. 69-86.
BRILLAT-SAVARIN, Jean Anthelme (1826), Physiologie du goût. Avec une lecture de Roland Barthes, Hermann, Paris 2005.
CARDOZO, Sidney B., HIRANO, Masaaki (1979), The Art of Rosanjin, Kodansha, Tokyo, 1987.
CWIERTKA, Katarzyna J. (2006), Modern Japanese Cuisine. Food, Power and National Identity, Reaktion, London.
DIACONU, Mădălina (2005), Tasten, Riechen, Schmecken. Eine Ästhetik der anästhesierten Sinne, Königshausen & Neumann,Würzburg.
DOUGLAS, Mary (1972), «Deciphering a Meal», in Daedalus, 101 (1), pp. 61-81.
DOUGLAS, Mary (1982), In the Active Voice, Routledge & Kegan Paul, London.
FISCHLER, Claude (1988), «Food, self and identity», in Social Science Information, 27 (2), pp. 275-292.
GOODMAN, Nelson (1968), Languages of Art. An Approach to a Theory of Symbols, Bobbs-Merrill, Indianapolis.
GOODMAN, Nelson (1978), Ways of Worldmaking, Hackett, Indianapolis.
GOODMAN, Nelson, ELGIN, Catherine Z. (1988), Reconceptions in Philosophy and other Arts and Sciences, Hackett, Indianapolis.
GROYS, Boris (1992), Über das Neue. Versuch einer Kulturökonomie, Fischer, Frankfurt 2004.
KORSMEYER, Carolyn (1999), Making Sense of Taste. Food and Philosophy, Ithaca, Cornell UP, London 2002.
LEMKE, Harald (2007), Die Kunst des Essens. Eine Ästhetik des kulinarischen Geschmacks, transcript, Bielefeld.
LÉVI-STRAUSS, Claude (1958), Structural Anthropology, Doubleday, Garden City, London 1967.
MALCOLM, Norman (2001), Ludwig Wittgenstein: A Memoir. Second Edition, Clarendon Press, Oxford.
NOVERO, Cecilia (2010), Antidiets of the Avant-Garde: From Futurist Cooking to Eat Art, University of Minnesota Press, Minneapolis.
SAITO, Yuriko (2007), Everyday Aesthetics, Oxford University Press, Oxford.
SCHUTZ, Alfred (1953), «Common-Sense and Scientific Interpretation of Human Action», in Collected Papers I: The Problem of Social Reality, Nijhoff, The Hague, 1962, pp. 3-47.
SCHUTZ, Alfred (1943), «The Problem of Rationality in the Social World», in Collected Papers II: Studies in Social Theory, Nijhoff, The Hague 1964, pp. 64-88.
SCHUTZ, Alfred (1957), «Some Structures of the Life-World», in Collected Papers III. Studies in Phenomenological Philosophy, Nijhoff, The Hague 1966, pp. 116-132.
SCHUTZ, Alfred (1951), «Reflections on the Problem of Relevance», in Collected Papers V. Phenomenology and the Social Sciences, Springer, Dordrecht 2011, pp. 93-199.
SCHUTZ, Alfred (2013), «Life Forms and Meaning Structures», in Collected Papers VI. Literary Reality and Relationships, Springer, Dordrecht 1925, pp. 37-115.
SPERBER, Dan, WILSON, Deirdre (1995), Relevance. Communication and Cognition. Second Edition, Blackwell, Oxford.
STANO, Simona (2015), Eating the Other: Translations of the Culinary Code, Cambridge Scholars, Newcastle upon Tyne.
STRASSHEIM, Jan (2010), «Relevance theories of communication: Alfred Schutz in dialogue with Sperber and Wilson», in Journal of Pragmatics, 42 (5), pp. 1412-1441.
STRASSHEIM, Jan (2016), «Type and spontaneity. Beyond Alfred Schutz's theory of the social world», in Human Studies, 39 (4), pp. 493-512.
STRASSHEIM, Jan (in press), «The ‘aesthetics of relevance’ in art and everyday life: A view from social phenomenology», in Annual review of the Phenomenological Association of Japan, 33.
SUGIYAMA, Takashi (2009), «Herder's Theory of Common Sense: The Birth of the Concept of Synesthesia», in Aesthetics, 13, pp. 69-81.
TELFER, Elizabeth (1995), Food as Art, in NEILL, Alex, RIDLEY, Aaron (eds.), Arguing About Art. Contemporary Philosophical Debates, Routledge, London 2002, pp. 9-27.
WILSON, Deirdre, CARSTON, Robyn (2007), A unitary approach to lexical pragmatics: Relevance, inference and ad hoc concepts, in BURTON-ROBERTS, Noel (ed.), Pragmatics, Basingstoke, Palgrave, pp. 230-259.
WILSON, Deirdre, SPERBER, Dan (2012), Meaning and Relevance, Cambridge University Press, Cambridge.
Works published in RIFL are released under Creative Commons Licence:Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.
